Shangpu Consulting: Necessary Conditions and Advantages of National Manufacturing Individual Champion Proof-Shangpu Consulting Company

Your location:Home Page > About Us > Expert opinion > Enterprise Training > Shawson >

Teaching Feedback for Corporate Training: Top 10 Feedback You Need to Collect and Analyze

2024-07-23 23:22:21 来源：尚普咨询浏览量：0

企业培训是指企业为了提高员工的知识、技能、态度和行为，而组织和实施的各种教育活动。企业培训可以帮助员工适应岗位需求，提升工作效率和质量，增强团队合作和沟通能力，促进个人发展和职业生涯规划等。然而，企业培训也需要投入大量的时间、精力和资金，因此如何评估培训的效果和价值，以及如何优化培训的设计和实施，成为了企业关注的重要问题。

教学反馈是一种常用的评估方法，它指的是在培训过程中或者结束后，通过各种方式收集培训者、受训者、管理者等相关人员对于培训内容、方法、环境、效果等方面的意见、建议、感受等信息，并对这些信息进行整理、分析、归纳、总结等处理，以便于发现培训过程和结果的优势和不足，以及改进和提升的方向。教学反馈可以帮助培训者了解受训者的需求、满意度、收获、困惑等情况，以及管理者对于培训目标、计划、执行、效果等方面的期望、评价、支持等情况，从而调整和改善培训内容、方法、环境等要素，提高培训质量和效果。

根据教学反馈的来源、内容、时间等不同维度，可以将教学反馈分为以下十种类型：

反馈表：这是一种最常见也最简单的教学反馈方式，通常在培训结束后或者每个模块结束后发放给受训者填写。反馈表可以包含一些量化或者定性的问题，例如对于培训内容、方法、环境等方面的满意度打分，或者对于培训的收获、建议、感想等方面的描述。反馈表的优点是可以快速、方便、系统地收集受训者的意见，但是缺点是可能存在一些表面化、敷衍、不真实等问题，因此需要设计合理的问题和选项，以及保证反馈的自愿性和匿名性。

小组讨论：这是一种更深入也更互动的教学反馈方式，通常在培训过程中或者结束后安排一段时间，让受训者分成几个小组，就培训的相关话题进行讨论，并由一个小组代表汇报讨论结果。小组讨论可以激发受训者的思考和交流，增加反馈的深度和广度，也可以增强受训者的参与感和归属感。但是小组讨论也需要注意控制时间和话题，避免偏离主题或者出现争执等情况。

个人采访：这是一种更私密也更真实的教学反馈方式，通常在培训结束后或者过了一段时间后，由培训者或者其他专业人员对部分或者全部受训者进行一对一的采访，询问他们对于培训的看法、感受、收获、困惑等情况。个人采访可以获取受训者更详细、更真实、更个性化的反馈，也可以增加受训者的信任感和尊重感。但是个人采访也需要花费更多的时间和精力，以及保证采访的专业性和隐私性。

观察记录：这是一种更客观也更全面的教学反馈方式，通常在培训过程中或者结束后，由培训者或者其他专业人员对受训者在培训中的表现、行为、互动等情况进行观察和记录。观察记录可以反映受训者对于培训内容、方法、环境等方面的兴趣、态度、参与度、理解度等情况，也可以发现培训中存在的问题和障碍。但是观察记录也需要注意选择合适的观察对象、指标、方法和工具，以及保证观察的公正性和有效性。

测试评估：这是一种更准确也更量化的教学反馈方式，通常在培训开始前、结束后或者过了一段时间后，对受训者进行一些测试或者评估，以检验他们在培训前后在知识、技能、态度等方面的变化和提升。测试评估可以提供受训者在培训中的学习效果和成果的直接证据，也可以为培训效果的评价提供可靠的数据支持。但是测试评估也需要注意设计合理的测试或者评估内容、标准、方法和工具，以及保证测试或者评估的公平性和科学性。

行为观察：这是一种更实际也更长期的教学反馈方式，通常在培训结束后或者过了一段时间后，由管理者或者其他专业人员对受训者在工作中的表现、行为、成果等情况进行观察和记录。行为观察可以反映受训者是否能够将培训中学到的知识、技能、态度等应用到工作中，以及应用的效果和影响如何。行为观察可以提供受训者在培训后的工作效果和价值的直接证据，也可以为培训效果的评价提供可靠的数据支持。但是行为观察也需要注意选择合适的观察对象、指标、方法和工具，以及保证观察的公正性和有效性。

业绩指标：这是一种更具体也更客观的教学反馈方式，通常在培训结束后或者过了一段时间后，对受训者所在的部门或者项目的业绩指标进行收集和分析，以衡量培训对于业绩的影响和贡献。业绩指标可以包括销售额、利润率、客户满意度、员工满意度、市场份额、产品质量、创新能力等各种与培训目标相关的指标。业绩指标可以提供受训者在培训后的业绩效果和价值的直接证据，也可以为培训效果的评价提供可靠的数据支持。但是业绩指标也需要注意选择合适的指标、方法和工具，以及排除其他因素的干扰和影响。

案例分析：这是一种更生动也更有说服力的教学反馈方式，通常在培训结束后或者过了一段时间后，对受训者在工作中遇到的一些典型或者成功的案例进行收集和分析，以展示培训对于解决问题和创造价值的作用和贡献。案例分析可以包括案例的背景、问题、分析、解决方案、结果、启示等方面。案例分析可以提供受训者在培训后的工作效果和价值的直接证据，也可以为培训效果的评价提供可靠的数据支持。但是案例分析也需要注意选择合适的案例、方法和工具，以及保证案例的真实性和代表性。

故事分享：这是一种更有趣也更有感染力的教学反馈方式，通常在培训结束后或者过了一段时间后，邀请受训者或者其他相关人员分享他们在培训中或者后经历的一些有意义或者有感触的故事，以展示培训对于个人发展和团队建设的作用和贡献。故事分享可以包括故事的情节、人物、情感、启示等方面。故事分享可以提供受训者在培训后的个人效果和价值的直接证据，也可以为培训效果的评价提供可靠的数据支持。但是故事分享也需要注意选择合适的故事、方法和工具，以及保证故事的真实性和感染力。

反思日志：这是一种更深刻也更持久的教学反馈方式，通常在培训过程中或者结束后或者过了一段时间后，要求受训者或者其他相关人员记录他们在培训中或者后的一些思考、感悟、收获、困惑等情况，以展示培训对于个人成长和学习的作用和贡献。反思日志可以包括反思的主题、内容、结论等方面。反思日志可以提供受训者在培训后的个人效果和价值的直接证据，也可以为培训效果的评价提供可靠的数据支持。但是反思日志也需要注意选择合适的主题、方法和工具，以及保证反思的深度和持续性。

以上就是本文介绍的十种教学反馈的类型和方法，以及如何收集和分析这些反馈，以提高企业培训的质量和效果。当然，这些类型和方法并不是固定或者唯一的，可以根据不同的培训目标、内容、对象、环境等情况进行选择、组合、创新等，以适应不同的培训需求和场景。同时，教学反馈也不是一个孤立或者单向的过程，而是一个循环或者双向的过程，需要在培训前、中、后不断地进行收集、分析、应用、改进等，以实现培训的持续改进和优化。

为了更好地说明教学反馈在实践中的应用和价值，本文将结合尚普咨询服务客户的具体案例进行简单分析。尚普咨询是一家专业从事企业管理咨询和培训服务的公司，拥有多年的行业经验和专业团队，为各行各业的企业提供定制化的解决方案和优质服务。尚普咨询在每次为客户提供培训服务时，都会根据客户的需求和特点，选择合适的教学反馈类型和方法，以保证培训效果和客户满意度。

以下是尚普咨询为某家汽车制造企业提供的一次培训服务的案例：

该企业为了提升员工的创新能力和产品质量，委托尚普咨询为其提供一次为期三天的创新思维培训。尚普咨询在设计培训方案时，考虑到创新思维是一种需要实践和体验的能力，因此采用了多种教学反馈方式，以增加培训效果和价值。

首先，在培训开始前，尚普咨询对受训者进行了一个简单的测试评估，以了解他们对于创新思维的基本认识和水平，并根据测试结果调整了培训内容和难度。

其次，在培训过程中，尚普咨询安排了多种教学活动，如小组讨论、案例分析、故事分享等，并在每个活动结束后收集受训者的反馈表或者观察记录，以了解他们对于活动内容、方法、环境等方面的满意度、参与度、理解度等情况，并根据反馈情况调整了活动设计和实施。

最后，在培训结束后，尚普咨询对受训者进行了一个复杂的测试评估，以检验他们在培训后在创新思维方面的变化和提升，并与培训前的测试结果进行对比和分析。同时，尚普咨询还对部分受训者进行了个人采访，以获取他们对于培训的看法、感受、收获、困惑等情况。此外，尚普咨询还要求受训者在培训结束后的一个月内，记录他们在工作中应用创新思维的一些案例或者故事，并提交给尚普咨询进行行为观察和案例分析，以衡量培训对于工作效果和价值的影响和贡献。

通过这些教学反馈方式的收集和分析，尚普咨询得到了以下结论：

受训者在培训后在创新思维方面有了明显的提升，测试评估的平均分从培训前的60分提高到了培训后的85分，其中有80%的受训者达到了90分以上的水平。

受训者对于培训内容、方法、环境等方面都表示了高度的满意度和认可度，反馈表的平均分为4.5points (the full score is5分），其中有90%的受训者给出了4分以上的评价。

受训者在培训中表现出了积极的参与度和互动度，小组讨论、案例分析、故事分享等活动都得到了受训者的热烈响应和投入，观察记录显示受训者在活动中的平均发言次数为5次，平均发言时间为3分钟。

受训者在培训后在工作中能够有效地应用创新思维，解决问题和创造价值，行为观察和案例分析显示受训者在工作中提出了多项创新性的建议和方案，并得到了管理者和客户的认可和支持，业绩指标也有了显著的提升。

受训者在培训后对于个人发展和团队建设都有了更深刻的理解和感悟，个人采访和反思日志显示受训者对于培训的收获、感想、启示等方面都有了更丰富和更深刻的描述，并表示了对于培训带来的变化和影响的感激和赞赏。

综上所述，尚普咨询为该企业提供的创新思维培训是一次成功且有效的培训服务，通过多种教学反馈方式的收集和分析，尚普咨询不仅保证了培训过程和结果的优质和高效，而且展示了自己作为一家专业咨询公司的能力和价值。该企业也对于尚普咨询提供的培训服务表示了高度的满意度和信任度，并表示愿意与尚普咨询保持长期合作关系。

Consulting Services

economic database

Brand Rankings

User evaluation

Champu Consulting-Market Research & Consulting China Pioneer

immediate consultation

On July 05, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for the "In-process Plastic Market Research Project in the Automotive Sector. The customer said: The project report completed by Shangpu Consulting in cooperation with our company is due to the wide range of projects and strong professional products. Thank you very much for the professional and detailed market research report of Shangpu Consulting. I look forward to cooperating again next time and wish Shangpu Consulting by going up one storey! Once again, I would like to thank the users for their support and wish them a prosperous career and an evergreen foundation!
On July 05, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for the "Research Project of the Network Designated City Transport Company. The customer said: The market research project provided by Shangpu Consulting for our company has provided us with a valuable reference basis for objectively evaluating the current market situation of the industry and achieved the expected goal. I also wish Champ Consulting the development of by going up one storey! Once again, I would like to thank the users for their support and wish them a prosperous career and an evergreen foundation!
On July 07, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for "A Brand Sales Leading Research Project in the Water Purifier Industry. The customer said: The market research project provided by Shangpu Consulting for our company has provided us with a valuable reference basis for objectively evaluating the current market situation of the industry and achieved the expected goal. I also wish Champ Consulting the development of by going up one storey! Once again, I would like to thank the users for their support and wish them a prosperous career and an evergreen foundation!
July 07, 2020, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer's "Lithium Battery Enterprise Sales Strategy and Production Cost Research Project. The customer said: The market research project provided by Shangpu Consulting for our company has provided us with a valuable reference basis for objectively evaluating the current market situation of the industry and achieved the expected goal. I also wish Champ Consulting the development of by going up one storey! Once again, I would like to thank the users for their support and wish them a prosperous career and an evergreen foundation!
On July 07, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for the "Coal Mine Tunnel Drilling Rig Market Share Proof Project. The customer said: The survey plan of Shangpu Consulting is rigorous in design, scientific in method, standardized and rigorous in survey organization process, and basically reliable survey data, which provides relatively credible first-hand information for our research work. The research results are of great help to our company to understand the whole picture of the industry. Once again, I would like to thank the users for their support and wish them a prosperous career and an evergreen foundation!
On July 07, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from a customer for "A Brand in an Industry Leading Sales Research Project for Three Consecutive Years. The customer said: The survey plan of Shangpu Consulting is rigorous in design, scientific in method, standardized and rigorous in survey organization process, and basically reliable survey data, which provides relatively credible first-hand information for our research work. The research results are of great help to our company to understand the whole picture of the industry. Once again, I would like to thank the users for their support and wish them a prosperous career and an evergreen foundation!
On July 07, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for the "China Bird's Nest Industry Market Ranking Research Project. The customer said: has cooperated many times, as always satisfied, also recommend to other enterprises cooperation. Once again, I would like to thank the users for their support and wish them a prosperous career and an evergreen foundation!
On July 09, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for a hazardous waste treatment research project. The customer said: this is the organizational structure of the survey, the service process is very good, wish your company's consulting work is getting better and better, look forward to the next cooperation. I wish users a prosperous career, evergreen foundation!
On July 16, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for the Shared Beauty Research Project. The customer said: The content of Phase I and Phase II is satisfactory, and we look forward to signing a long-term agreement in the later period. The research part of the country will continue to cooperate with your company. I wish users a prosperous career, evergreen foundation!
On July 09, 2021, Shangpu Consulting received a satisfaction evaluation sheet from the customer for the "Research Project on the Organizational Structure of Two Liquor Production Enterprises. The customer said: This is an organizational structure survey, the service process is very good, looking forward to the next cooperation. I wish users a prosperous career, evergreen foundation!

In the field of consulting, Champ Consulting can also provide you with the following services:

Research Module	research content
Market research	Industry status	market capacity	Product Application	channel mode	Supply chain	market competition	Market Consulting
Competitor Research	Enterprise background	Enterprise Finance	Sales Data	Market Strategy	Production Equipment	Supply Procurement	Technology R & D
Competitor Research	warehousing logistics	channel construction	Human Resources	Enterprise Strategy
User Research	Consumer Survey	consumption behavior attitude	Publicity/Promotion	Product Service	Brand Research	consumer characteristics
User Research	satisfaction survey	Employee satisfaction	user satisfaction
Market Entry Advisory	Macro Industry Research	competitive enterprise research	Downstream User Research	Channel Research	Due Diligence	Return on Investment
Market Entry Advisory	Floor module	Landing implementation recommendations	Long-term cooperation
Business investment due diligence	Target industry market investment value due diligence	Industry Benchmarking Enterprise Research	Target Enterprise Credit Assessment Report	Project investment due diligence
industry planning	Market research	market access	development strategy	investment location	Acquisition and integration	IPO Fundraising
Credit Report	Basic information	Major Events	Production/Operation Network	enterprise scale	Operating strength	Financial strength	Legal risk
Credit Report	Future business prediction	Overall credit rating	cooperative risk warning
Brand/Sales Proof	Market Share Proof	Market Share Proof	Proof of brand strength	Industry Proof	Specialized new proof	Proof of sales strength	Proof of technological leadership
Brand/Sales Proof	National/Global Status Certificate

Service advantages

More than 20 years of focus on the Chinese market consulting, won the user recognition, user satisfaction reached more than 96%, the following is part of the user praise

Focus on production and research

15 Year

Champ Consulting has been established for 15 years.

48 Intellectual Property Rights

Independent methodology

80% of the information comes from first-hand research.
massive data

118 Billionth

Self-built database 11.8 billion

Covering 1978 industries in China

0.1 billion new data per year

Industry Big Data Platform
Research Team

118 +

Have a 300 team of professional consultants

Practical operation and management experience of top enterprises

88% of members have international PMP certificates
Intellectual Property

48 Item

Independent methodology

48 independent intellectual property rights

high-tech enterprise

Industry Big Data Platform

Customer Evaluation

More than 20 years of focus on the Chinese market consulting, won the user recognition, user satisfaction reached more than 96%, the following is part of the user praise